Joe Allman and David Sims of Forbes Solicitors secure acquittal in a unique historic sexual offences case involving “recovered memory”
The client was acquitted of all charges after a two-week trial at Burnley Crown Court.
The case concerned 23 historic sexual offence charges based on allegations by two complainants. The defence argued that one had developed false memories and the other had made malicious allegations.
Both complainants and a third party claimed to have heard the client confess when confronted. The prosecution unsuccessfully sought to exclude expert evidence on false and recovered memory. Prosecution and defence experts then gave evidence in succession. The prosecution expert was cross-examined on autosuggestion and false memory in the context of alternative therapies and the complainant’s own research. The expert accepted that autosuggestion can create false memories and that the book “The Power to Heal” made unwarranted claims about recovered memories that could lead readers to believe they had been abused.
The second complainant was challenged on whether she had influenced the first complainant’s recollection and fabricated her own account.
Both complainants and the third party were challenged on their recollection of the alleged confession.
The client was acquitted on all charges.
Joe Allman was instructed by David Sims of Forbes Solicitors.
For further information or to instruct Joe Allman, contact Andy McGuinness, Senior Criminal Clerk.